| General information | |
|---|---|
| Number | P262233/ENF |
| Current status | Pending Appeal |
| Decision | |
| Appeal decision | |
| Type | Enforcement Appeal |
| Location | Land at Rookrow Farm Mathon Malvern Herefordshire WR13 5PR |
| Proposal | Enforcement Appeal |
| Parish | Mathon |
| Ward | Hope End |
| Easting/Northing | 372557 - 245558 |
| Case officer | Andrew Banks |
| Agent address | Berrys Shiretown House 41-43 Broad Street Hereford Herefordshire HR4 9AR |
| Applicant address | A S Green & Co C/o Agent |
| Publicity date | Monday 17 August 2026 |
| Application dates | |
|---|---|
| Date received | Monday 27 July 2026 |
| Date validated | Wednesday 5 August 2026 |
| Consultation start date | Monday 17 August 2026 |
| Appeal date | Wednesday 19 August 2026 |
| Target determination date | Wednesday 30 September 2026 |
| Consultees | |
|---|---|
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Mathon PC |
| Address | 9 Lambourne Avenue Malvern Worcestershire WR14 1NL |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Bosbury PC |
| Address | Hadleigh Bishops Frome Worcester WR6 5AP |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Coddington PC |
| Address | Hadleigh Bishops Frome Worcester WR6 5AP |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Hope End |
| Address | 2 Canon Frome Court Canon Frome Ledbury HR8 2TD |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Severn Trent Water |
| Address | Operations Management Asset Protection Team Regis Road Tettenhall WV6 8RU |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | |
| Address | West Midlands Region Whitcliffe Ludlow Shropshire SY8 2HD |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | AONB Officer |
| Address | Malvern Hills National Landscape Partnership Office, Manor House Grange Road Worcestershire WR14 3EY |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Land Drainage |
| Address | Herefordshire Council Plough Lane Hereford Herefordshire HR4 0LE |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council |
| Address | Transportation H37 Plough Lane H37 |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Ecology |
| Address | Herefordshire Council Plough Lane Hereford Herefordshire HR4 0LE |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Built and Natural Environment |
| Address | Herefordshire Council Plough Lane Hereford HR4 0LE |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Operations Delivery |
| Address | Consultations Team (Natural England) County Hall Spetchley Road Worcester WR5 2NP |
| Date consulted | 17 August 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Operations Delivery |
| Address | Consultations Team (Natural England) County Hall Spetchley Road Worcester WR5 2NP |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Hope End |
| Address | 2 Canon Frome Court Canon Frome Ledbury HR8 2TD |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Mathon PC |
| Address | 9 Lambourne Avenue Malvern Worcestershire WR14 1NL |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Bosbury PC |
| Address | Hadleigh Bishops Frome Worcester WR6 5AP |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Coddington PC |
| Address | Hadleigh Bishops Frome Worcester WR6 5AP |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Severn Trent Water |
| Address | Operations Management Asset Protection Team Regis Road Tettenhall WV6 8RU |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | |
| Address | West Midlands Region Whitcliffe Ludlow Shropshire SY8 2HD |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | AONB Officer |
| Address | Malvern Hills National Landscape Partnership Office, Manor House Grange Road Worcestershire WR14 3EY |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Land Drainage |
| Address | Herefordshire Council Plough Lane Hereford Herefordshire HR4 0LE |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Ecology |
| Address | Herefordshire Council Plough Lane Hereford Herefordshire HR4 0LE |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Built and Natural Environment |
| Address | Herefordshire Council Plough Lane Hereford HR4 0LE |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council |
| Address | Transportation H37 Plough Lane H37 |
| Date consulted | 1 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Cradley & Storridge PC |
| Address | The Beeches Edwyn Ralph Bromyard HR7 4LY |
| Date consulted | 9 September 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Hope End |
| Address | 2 Canon Frome Court Canon Frome Ledbury HR8 2TD |
| Date consulted | 10 November 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Mathon PC |
| Address | 9 Lambourne Avenue Malvern Worcestershire WR14 1NL |
| Date consulted | 10 November 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Bosbury PC |
| Address | Hadleigh Bishops Frome Worcester WR6 5AP |
| Date consulted | 10 November 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Coddington PC |
| Address | Hadleigh Bishops Frome Worcester WR6 5AP |
| Date consulted | 10 November 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Cradley & Storridge PC |
| Address | The Beeches Edwyn Ralph Bromyard HR7 4LY |
| Date consulted | 10 November 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Operations Delivery |
| Address | Consultations Team (Natural England) County Hall Spetchley Road Worcester WR5 2NP |
| Date consulted | 10 November 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Severn Trent Water |
| Address | Operations Management Asset Protection Team Regis Road Tettenhall WV6 8RU |
| Date consulted | 10 November 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | |
| Address | West Midlands Region Whitcliffe Ludlow Shropshire SY8 2HD |
| Date consulted | 10 November 2026 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | AONB Officer |
| Address | Malvern Hills National Landscape Partnership Office, Manor House Grange Road Worcestershire WR14 3EY |
| Date consulted | 10 November 2026 |
Relevant documents
Appeal (155)
- CD11.4.8 Appendix 8 PPG excerpt Rural Workers Paragraph 10 147KB
- CD11.4.7 Appendix 7 Nationally_Described_Space_Standard March 2015 310KB
- CD11.4.6 Appendix 6 HLCA Chapter 7 LCT5 1.0MB
- R CD11.4.5 Appendix 5 P240414U LDC Refused Berrys statement 2.0MB
- R CD11.4.4 Appendix 4 P214472F CLEUD application withdrawn Berry - Copy 2.8MB
- CD11.4.3 Appendix 3 Fuller v SSE [1988] 56 P and C.R. 84 461KB
- CD11.4.2 Appendix 2. Burdle v Secretary of State [1972] 1 WLR 1207 543KB
- CD11.42 Appeal Decision 3374518 Highfield Heights Enforcement 268KB
- CD11.41 Appeal Decision - 3372695 Micklefield 142KB
- CD11.40 Appeal Decision - 3366426 Bangors Park 227KB
- CD11.39 3319435-Appeal-Decision - Dan Tree Fm enforcement 514KB
- CD11.38.11- RRF view of doors open - view 5.4MB
- CD11.38.10 - RRF site view towards the We 5.4MB
- CD11.38.9 - RRF 10 11 14 18 7 13 - view to South East 33 caravans plus rear of sheds 2026-09-20 5.3MB
- CD11.38.8- RRF 2 21 6 9 13 - view to North East of the Yard 2026-09-20 4.6MB
- CD11.38.7 - RRF north facing view of the site with Malvern Hills AONB to rear 2026-09-19 2.9MB
- CD11.38.6 - RRF east view listed building with close caravan and packhouse 2026-09-19 1.7MB
- CD11.38.5 - RRF West row of 8 cabin doors visible 2026-09-19 2.1MB
- CD11.38.4 - RRF SE view of RRF site in re 1.5MB
- CD11.38.3- RRF full angled view looking North from Moorend Court 2026-09-19 1.7MB
- CD11.38.2 - RRF 16 17 - view of cabins and containarised buildings 2026-09-19 1.1MB
- CD11.38.1 - RRF 12 8 3 5 - closer view looking south of listed building rear 2 2026-09-19 1.3MB
- CD11.37 Core Strategy Map 2.4MB
- CD11.36 Historic Google Earth images 1.7MB
- CD11.35 Aerial Photos of site taken 25.05.2016 purchased from Air Images 16.09.2026crop 2.4MB
- CD11.35 Aerial Photos of site taken 25.05.2016 purchased from Air Images 16.09.2026 3.8MB
- CD11.34 Questions for the Appellant sent via email by John Vale at Plan A to Berrys 29.09.2026 181KB
- CD11.33 Herefordshire Council AMR October 2025 634KB
- CD11.32 Historic England - GPA 2 - Managing significance in decision-making in historic env. 03 2015 239KB
- CD11.31 Historic England - Listing Selection Guide - Domestic 1 - Vernacular Houses Dec 2019 2.6MB
- CD11.30 Historic England - Good Practice Advice 3 - The setting of heritage assets Dec 2017 336KB
- CD11.29 Historic England - Statements of Heritage Significance HE Advice_note 12 Oct 2019 374KB
- CD11.28 Herefordshire Planning Obligations SPD (April 2008) 341KB
- CD11.20 Manual for Streets 2 9.5MB
- CD 11.16 Bonsall v SSCLG [2016] QB 811 154KB
- CD11.26 Technical housing standards - May 2015 310KB
- CD11.25 Appeal Decision APP_C1435_W_24_3337769 135KB
- CD11.24 Appeal Decision APP_A1910_W_23_3323376 94KB
- CD11.23 Appeal Decision APP_V3120_A_09_2101627 287KB
- CD11.22 Appeal Decision APP_Y2003_W_25_3372031 109KB
- CD11.21 CD123 of the DMRB 6.9MB
- CD11.19 Site Location Plan 727KB
- CD 11.18 Fuller v SSE [1988] 56 P and C.R. 84 461KB
- CD 11.17 Jones v Isle of Anglesey CC [2025] JPL 882 257KB
- TO CHECK NOT PUBLISHED CD11.8 Burdle v Secretary of State [1972] 1 WLR 1207 543KB
- CD11.13 Fewings v SSCLG [2008] EWHC 2401 157KB
- CD11.12 Harrods Ltd v SSETR [2002] JPL 437 106KB
- CD11.11 Beach v SSETR [2001] EWHC 381 111KB
- CD11.10 Westminster City Council v British Waterways Board [1985] AC 676 170KB
- CD11.9 Impey v Secretary of State [1980] 47 P & CR 157.pdf 367KB
- CD 11.15 Sellars v Basingstoke and Deane BC [2013] EWHC 3673 83KB
- CD 11.14 Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council v SSCLG [2011] 2 AC 304 210KB
- Revised Indicative Programme 167KB
- CD11.4.1 Appendix 1. Statement of Case - Berrys 660KB
- R CD11.7 Tym Musgrove Statement 27.10.2026 2.5MB
- R CD11.6.14 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 19 2.8MB
- R CD11.6.13 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 18 2.1MB
- R CD11.6.12 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 17 1.8MB
- R CD11.6.11 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 16 1.9MB
- R CD11.6.10 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 15(2of2) 9.7MB
- R CD11.6.10Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 15 (1 of 2) 11.0MB
- R CD11.6.9 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 14 2.6MB
- R CD11.6.8 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 13 1.9MB
- R CD11.6.7 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 11 (2of2) 15.0MB
- R CD11.6.7 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 11 (1 of 2) 11.7MB
- R CD11.6.6 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 8 1.9MB
- R CD11.6.5 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 6 1.8MB
- R CD11.6.4 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 5 2.6MB
- R CD11.6.3 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 4 5.1MB
- R CD11.6.2 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM 3 6.8MB
- R CD11.6.1 Antonia Musgrove Exhibit AM1 1.4MB
- R CD11.6 Antonia Musgrove Statement 27.10.26 6.8MB
- R CD11.5 Fiona Bulmer Signed Witness Statement 27Oct2026 4.1MB
- CD 11.4 Rook Row Farm Proof of Evidence John Vale - Planning 704KB
- CD11.3 Proof of Evidence NCF Heritage Oct 2026 810KB
- CD11.2 Proof of Evidence - Nathan Hanks - Highways 1.9MB
- CD9.1 - APPEAL DECISION 3355953 282KB
- R CD8.14- Planning Statement prepared for application 214472 2.8MB
- R CD8.12 - Photographs by Built Heritage Team - May 2022 and May 2024 1.7MB
- CD 8.16 - Manual for Streets 2007 5.0MB
- CD 8.15 - LPA PoE - Katy Jones - Highways 993KB
- CD 8.13 - HEGPAN GPA3 - The setting of Heritage Assets 336KB
- CD 8.11 - Built Heritage Officer Comments - 23rd May 2024 455KB
- CD 8.10 - Built Heritage Officer Comments - 16 May 2022 (2) 96KB
- CD 8.9 - Historic England List Desc and Map (1) 169KB
- CD 8.8 - LPA PoE - Debra Lewis - Heritage 407KB
- CD 8.7 - LPA PoE - Andrew Banks - Planning 230KB
- CD7.4.24 Appendix X - NFU Letter 197KB
- CD7.4.23 Appendix W - Block Plan 209KB
- R CD7.4.22 Appendix V - CMC note Rook Row Farm v3 94KB
- R CD7.4.21 Appendix U - Statement of Case 1.0MB
- CD7.4.20 Appendix T - Local Farms Now and 20 years ago 8.4MB
- R CD7.4.19 Appendix S - Sand Fields Farm Letter 124KB
- R CD7.4.18 Appendix R - Pro Force Letter 45KB
- CD7.4.17 Appendix Q - Rook Row Farmhouse Listing 239KB
- R CD7.4.16 Appendix P - Kenya Article 1.6MB
- R CD7.4.15 Appendix O - Article 1.6MB
- R CD7.4.14 Appendix N - Article 54KB
- CD7.4.13 Appendix M - Landscape Officer Comments 136KB
- CD7.4.12 Appendix L - LVIA 4.9MB
- CD7.4.11 Appendix K - Aerial Images 1.7MB
- R CD7.4.10 Appendix J - KC Opinion 321KB
- CD7.4-S - SUMMARY Proof of Evidence (Planning) 458KB
- CD7.1-S - SUMMARY Proof of Evidence (Highways) 101KB
- CD7.4.9 Appendix I - Enforcement Notice 2.4MB
- R CD7.4.8 Appendix H - Seasonal Worker Application 6.7MB
- R CD7.4.7 Appendix G - Email 137KB
- CD7.4.6 Appendix F - B2 B8 Certificate Application 7.7MB
- R CD7.4.5 Appendix E - Packing House Extension 13.9MB
- CD7.4.4 Appendix D - Prior Approval 5.0MB
- CD7.4.3 Appendix C - Core Strategy 921KB
- CD7.4.2 Appendix B - NPPF 883KB
- R CD7.4.1 Appendix A - SoCG 2.7MB
- R CD7.4 - Proof of Evidence (Planning) 1.1MB
- R CD7.3-S - SUMMARY Proof of Evidence (Agriculture) 149KB
- R CD7.3 - Proof of Evidence (Agriculture) 1.4MB
- R CD7.2 - Proof of Evidence & Summary (Heritage) 9.8MB
- CD7.1 - Proof of Evidence (Highways) 949KB
- CD4.1 R SoCG - 20.10.26 11.4MB
- Rule 6 Party Rook Row Statement of Case 30 September 2026 291KB
- CD3.1 R Email from Appellant withdrawing Grounds (b) and (d) dated 12.10.26 84KB
- 10.1 CMC note Rook Row Farm 106KB
- CD8.6 LPA Annex _Suggested Planning Conditions 154KB
- CD8.5 LPA Appendix 4 - LPA HRA Appropriate Assessment 441KB
- CD8.4 LPA Appendix 3 - Transport Note Bulmer 2024 536KB
- CD8.3 LPA Appendix 2 - Officer Report 240414U 650KB
- CD8.2 R LPA Appendix 1 - Expediency Report 904KB
- CD8.1 LPA Statement of Case 373KB
- Letter from PINS dated 18/9/26 regarding Environmental Impact Assesment 177KB
- Update regarding the date and venue 53KB
- Rule 6 party comments 6013621 42KB
- R Rule 6 Letter PINS 11.08.26 829KB
- Rule 6 Annex B - Hereford Times 02 07 2026 1.3MB
- Rule 6 Annex A - Rook Row Farm in relation to Moorend Court 851KB
- Public Inquiry Start Letter 99KB
- New date for Inquiry 40KB
- New Appeal notification letter 153KB
- Rook Row Farmhouse Listing 251KB
- LPA - Rook Row Farm Enforcement Map Annotated 329KB
- LOCAL PLAN CORE STRATEGY POLICIES 137KB
- LPA - Enforcement Notice 673KB
- Appeal Notification Letter 153KB
- LAP Questionnaire Submission 97KB
- CD2.8 Appellant HA42535_P_02_F Block Plan 69KB
- CD2.7 Appellant LVIA Oct 2022 9.4MB
- CD2.3 R Final - Statement of Case against Enforcement Notice 27.07.2026 (SS amends) GJC 665KB
- R Appellant Statutory Declaration (sworn) 3.9MB
- R Appellant Rook Row Farm Drainage Report CWC458-RP01-Rev1 7.4MB
- R Appellant Enforcement Notice 25.06.2026 13.0MB
- Appellant Rook Row Farm Enforcement Map Annotated 69KB
- CD1.2 Appellant Enforcement Notice Site Plan 314KB
- CD2.1 Appellant Appeal 6013621 94KB
- CD2.2 Appellant A42535_P_01_F Location Plan 67KB
- CD2.5 R Appellant A S Green Ltd Staff number and Jobs 980KB
- Start Letter 291KB