| General information | |
|---|---|
| Number | P150765/F |
| Current status | Appeal Determined |
| Decision | Refused |
| Appeal decision | Allowed |
| Type | Planning Permission |
| Location | Trumpet Fields adjacent A438 Trumpet Ledbury Herefordshire HR8 2RA |
| Proposal | Erection of polytunnels on fields at Trumpet for covered commercial growing of soft fruit and new pond area. |
| Parish | Munsley |
| Ward | Frome - prior 2015 |
| Easting/Northing | 366269 - 239068 |
| Agent address | Antony Aspbury Associates Ltd Unit 20 Park Lane Business Centre Park Lane Basford Nottingham NG6 0DW |
| Applicant address | C/O Haygrove Ltd Redbank Farm Ledbury Herefordshire HR8 2JL |
| Publicity date | Tuesday 24 March 2015 |
| Comments by | Tuesday 13 October 2015 |
| Application dates | |
|---|---|
| Date received | Monday 16 March 2015 |
| Date validated | Thursday 19 March 2015 |
| Consultation start date | Tuesday 24 March 2015 |
| Consultation end date | Tuesday 13 October 2015 |
| Decision date | Thursday 15 October 2015 |
| Appeal date | Wednesday 27 April 2016 |
| Appeal decision date | Wednesday 17 August 2016 |
| Target determination date | Friday 23 October 2015 |
| Consultees | |
|---|---|
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | The Ramblers Association |
| Address | 98 Gorsty Lane Hereford Herefordshire HR1 1UN |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Open Spaces Society (South) |
| Address | 2 Woodside Cottages Welsh Newton Monmouth NP25 5RS |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Public Rights of Way Development Officer |
| Address | Balfour Beatty Unit 3 Thorn Business Park Rotherwas Industrial Estate HR2 6JT |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Casework Assistant |
| Address | Historic England The Axis 10 Holliday Street Birmingham B1 1TG |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Balfour Beatty Living Places |
| Address | Unit 3 Thorn Business Park Rotherwas Hereford HR2 6JT |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Environmental Health |
| Address | Council Offices Blueschool House Hereford Herefordshire HR1 2ZB |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Pixley PC |
| Address | Mapleside Ashperton Ledbury HR8 2RZ |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Frome |
| Address | Leadon Court Fromes Hill Ledbury HR8 1HT |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council (HB Officer) |
| Address | Herefordshire Council Plough Lane Hereford Herefordshire HR4 0LE |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council |
| Address | Blueschool House Blueschool Street Hereford Herefordshire HR1 2ZB |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council (Landscape Officer) |
| Address | Blueschool House Blueschool Street Hereford Herefordshire HR1 2LX |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council |
| Address | Transportation H37 Plough Lane H37 |
| Date consulted | 24 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Environment Agency |
| Address | Hafren House Welshpool Road Shelton Shrewsbury SY3 8BB |
| Date consulted | 26 March 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | The Ramblers Association |
| Address | 98 Gorsty Lane Hereford Herefordshire HR1 1UN |
| Date consulted | 7 April 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Economic Development Unit |
| Address | Plough Lane PO Box 4 Hereford HR4 0XH |
| Date consulted | 20 May 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Balfour Beatty Living Places |
| Address | Unit 3 Thorn Business Park Rotherwas Hereford HR2 6JT |
| Date consulted | 5 June 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Balfour Beatty Living Places |
| Address | Unit 3 Thorn Business Park Rotherwas Hereford HR2 6JT |
| Date consulted | 10 June 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council |
| Address | Blueschool House Blueschool Street Hereford Herefordshire HR1 2LX |
| Date consulted | 10 June 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Balfour Beatty Living Places |
| Address | Unit 3 Thorn Business Park Rotherwas Hereford HR2 6JT |
| Date consulted | 27 July 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Balfour Beatty Living Places |
| Address | Unit 3 Thorn Business Park Rotherwas Hereford HR2 6JT |
| Date consulted | 28 August 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council |
| Address | Blueschool House Blueschool Street Hereford Herefordshire HR1 2LX |
| Date consulted | 28 August 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Transport and Access Services |
| Address | Herefordshire Council H37 Plough Lane Hereford HR4 0LE |
| Date consulted | 21 September 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Pixley PC |
| Address | Mapleside Ashperton Ledbury HR8 2RZ |
| Date consulted | 21 September 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Munsley PC |
| Address | Mapleside Ashperton Ledbury Herefordshire HR8 2RZ |
| Date consulted | 21 September 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council |
| Address | Blueschool House Blueschool Street Hereford Herefordshire HR1 2LX |
| Date consulted | 21 September 2015 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Balfour Beatty Living Places |
| Address | Unit 3 Thorn Business Park Rotherwas Hereford HR2 6JT |
| Date consulted | 21 March 2016 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council |
| Address | Blueschool House Blueschool Street Hereford Herefordshire HR1 2LX |
| Date consulted | 28 April 2016 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Three Crosses |
| Address | 54 Mount Pleasant New Road Bromyard Herefordshire HR7 4AN |
| Date consulted | 28 April 2016 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Pixley PC |
| Address | Mapleside Ashperton Ledbury HR8 2RZ |
| Date consulted | 28 April 2016 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Munsley PC |
| Address | Mapleside Ashperton Ledbury Herefordshire HR8 2RZ |
| Date consulted | 28 April 2016 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council |
| Address | Blueschool House Blueschool Street Hereford Herefordshire HR1 2LX |
| Date consulted | 25 October 2016 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Herefordshire Council |
| Address | Herefordshire Council Plough Lane Hereford Herefordshire HR4 0LE |
| Date consulted | 25 October 2016 |
| Consultee | |
| Organisation name | Balfour Beatty Living Places |
| Address | Unit 3 Thorn Business Park Rotherwas Hereford HR2 6JT |
| Date consulted | 9 November 2016 |
Relevant documents
Application Form (1)
- R App Form 497KB
Decisions (4)
Appeal (56)
- Email to PINS 11.8.16 264KB
- Email from PINS 10.8.16 158KB
- Email from LPA to Planning Inspectorate dated 30.6.2016 177KB
- Email including drawing TFP008 from agent dated 29.6.16 465KB
- Email to PINS Dated 23.06.16 452KB
- R Appellant's Rebuttal Statement - Annex 5 1.3MB
- R Appellant's Rebuttal Statement received 20.6.16 15.6MB
- Appellant's Rebuttal Statement - Trumpet Appeal Note TPP-008 910KB
- Appellant's Rebuttal Statement - Post Determination Drawing TFP008 637KB
- Appellant's Rebuttal Statement - Annex 4 4.7MB
- Appellant's Rebuttal Statement - Annex 3 1.1MB
- Appellant's Rebuttal Statement - Annex 2 1.9MB
- Appellant's Rebuttal Statement - Annex 1 3.2MB
- Email from Apppellant to PINS 20.6.16 280KB
- R Pixley & District PC Comments 3.2MB
- R Mr S Thirlwell Comments 2.8MB
- R Ms M Fielding Comments 2.8MB
- R Mr N & Mrs C Casdagli Comments 44KB
- R Mr R Denman Comments 30KB
- R Ms F Robinson Comments 62KB
- R Mr G Purves Comments 112KB
- R CPRE Comments 109KB
- R Mr C Thwaites Comments 166KB
- R Ms L Melhuish Comments 15KB
- R Ms S Marcon Comments 23KB
- R Mr J & Mrs E Bouchier Comments 27KB
- Ms E Clothier Comments 3.4MB
- Mr PC Randall Comments 234KB
- Mr A & Mrs I Mawby Comments 145KB
- Letter Received PINS Dated 06.06.16 111KB
- R Email from PINS enc Representation Mr Barrett 10.6.16 85KB
- R LPA Statement of Case - Annex 4 32.8MB
- LPA Statement of Case - Annex 7 22.5MB
- LPA Statement of Case - Annex 9 701KB
- LPA Statement of Case - Annex 8 987KB
- LPA Statement of Case - Annex 6 11.1MB
- LPA Statement of Case - Annex 5 6.9MB
- LPA Statement of Case - Annex 3 1.7MB
- LPA Statement of Case - Annex 2 10.3MB
- LPA Statement of Case - Annex 1 15.6MB
- LPA Statement of Case 3.0MB
- Further Email from PINS re: appeal procedure 10.5.16 312KB
- Email from PINS confirming written representations procedure 10.5.16 199KB
- Email to PINS 29.4.16 307KB
- Appellant's Draft Statement of Common Ground 4.8MB
- Appellant's Written Statement of Evidence 8.7MB
- Policies 29.2MB
- Press Notice 2.4.15 2.3MB
- Site Notices 1.2MB
- Start Letter 2.0MB
- Notification Letter 799KB
- Notification List 431KB
- Appellant's Appeal Form 90KB
- LPA Questionnaire 113KB
- Email reply to PINS 21.4.16 450KB
- Email from PINS 21.4.16 353KB
Supporting Documents (15)
- DOC 5 - Further details received 20.1.17 1.8MB
- Further detail pursuant to condition 5 of planning permission 150765 543KB
- R Discharge of Condition 2 & 5 request - Landscape & Drainage Details 21.10.16 14.3MB
- R DOC 2 & 5 Request & Info. 26.2MB
- Tier 1 Risk Assessment for Baeza Pond received 17.3.2016 17:15 2.2MB
- Further submission from David Floyd re Water Management received 23.7.15 323KB
- Further Details of Pond(s) rec'd 10.6.15 749KB
- Addendum to Water Management Audit 4.6.15 5.8MB
- WMA Tables 2.1MB
- Water Management Audit 37.8MB
- Tree Survey & Arboricultural Constraints Report 16.6MB
- Landscape Appraisal 10.4MB
- Landscape & Ecology Management Plan 7.7MB
- Ecological Appraisal Report 20.2MB
- Design & Access & Planning Statement 27.2MB
Drawings (9)
- Approved landscaping plan 538KB
- Plan showing proposed new access onto the A438 received 18.09.15 437KB
- Plan showing closure of existing access onto the A438 received 18.09.15 247KB
- Baeza Pond Cross Section received 26.8.15 416KB
- Baeza Pond plan received 26.8.15 1.2MB
- Landscape Proposals 6.0MB
- LocationPlan 2.0MB
- Site Boundary & Other Land Owned by Aplicant 1.6MB
- Baeza Pond Cross Sections 708KB
Photographs (1)
- Aerial Photograph 1.7MB
Correspondence (33)
- Approval of landscaping details pursuant to condition 2 09.10.2017 202KB
- Further Drainage Advice received 13.1.17 1.6MB
- E-mail to agent for applicant re: details pursuant to condition 5 - 6.12.16 594KB
- E-mail to applicant regarding condition 5 dated 18.11.2016 3.5MB
- Post appeal decision e-amil from LPA to agent for appellant & appeallant dated 22/8/2016 236KB
- Email from Case Officer to Land Drainage Consultant dated 18.3.16 12:42 189KB
- E-mail received on 23rd March 2016 from the Council’s Land Drainage consultants advising that ground of refusal 2 can be withdrawn in the event of an appeal being lodged 347KB
- Email to Mr T Asbury 23.03.16 2.5MB
- Additional email to Land Drainage consultant 17.3.2016 18:11 344KB
- Email to Land Drainage Consultant 17.3.2016 18:11 344KB
- Post decision Email from applicant dated 17.3.2016 17:15 enclosing Tier 1 Risk Assessment for Baeza Pond 273KB
- Email to agent for the appellant dated 8.3.16 re: reason for refusal 2 291KB
- R Letter Rec'd Mr C Thwaites 27.10.15 119KB
- Email From Applicant Dated 4 September 16:41 187KB
- E-mail from Landscape Consultant (Carly Tinkler) acting for applicant received 26.8.15 08:35 320KB
- Email Exchange with Applicant 25.07.15 198KB
- Email exchange with Applicant 29.6.15 258KB
- Email exchange with Applicant 15.6.15 201KB
- Email exchange with Applicant 10.6.15 1.3MB
- Email to Applicant 08.06.15 192KB
- Correspondence with Applicant 8.6.15 297KB
- Email to Applicant 2.6.15 275KB
- Email to Aplicant 28.5.15 7.8MB
- Email from Elizabeth Duberley 28.5.15 15:21 427KB
- E mail Correspondence with Applicant - 28.5.15 355KB
- E mail Correspondence with Applicant - 28.5.15 130KB
- R Email correspondence with applicant 23.5.15 & 16.5.15 2.8MB
- R Email Correspondence with Mr & Mrs Mawby 25 & 26 May 2015 17KB
- E Mail Correspondence with Applicant - 26.5.15 395KB
- E Mail Correspondence with Applicant - 26.5.15 354KB
- R Letter from applicant 13.5.15 218KB
- Letter Sent Applicant 29.4.15 8.2MB
- Letter to applicant 46KB
Representations (22)
- View received on 23rd March 2016 from the Council’s Land Drainage consultants advising that ground of refusal 2 can be withdrawn in the event of an appeal being lodged 141KB
- Consultation response - Transportation 49KB
- Further landscape comments received on 8th September 2015 510KB
- Further e-mail received on 10th August 2015 from land drainage advisors objecting 315KB
- Land Drainage consultants - Further Comments 7.8.15 380KB
- Further Land Drainage Comments 186KB
- Parish Council Further Comments 99KB
- Further views from Balfour Beatty re: surface water management & flood risk 5th June 2015 349KB
- R Ledbury & District Civic Society Comments 27KB
- Land Drainage Comments 777KB
- Pixley PC Comments 196KB
- Land Drainage Comments 313KB
- CPRE Obj 132KB
- Land Drainage Consultant Comments 2.5MB
- Ecology Response 54KB
- Environment Agency Comments 183KB
- Landscape Officer Comments 3.1MB
- Parish Council Comments 635KB
- Consultation response - Transportation 59KB
- R Historic England Comments 488KB
- Herefordshire Ramblers - Leadon Vale Group Comments 172KB
- PROW Comments 2.1MB
Officer Report (1)
- DelegRpt 16.1MB